Nineteen Eighty-four (1984), George Orwell, 1946, Secker & Warburg.
It is possible to generate emotion by confronting the traits of a protagonist with the values of the world to which they belong.
In the “counter-utopian” world of Airstrip One, a province of Oceania (formerly England), the population is permanently monitored by cameras, microphones, spies of all kinds and the piercing gaze of the leader Big Brother, whose portrait is posted everywhere.
The expeditious methods of the Thought Police inspire such great terror that it nips in the bud any crime of opinion among the citizens. The ruling government (the Party) rewrites history and broadcasts its conspiracy propaganda on television sets that cannot be turned off.
The world of the plot follows the rules of totalitarian regimes (control of information, restriction of freedom, various repressions, state economy), while Winston Smith, the protagonist, a civil servant at the Ministry of Truth, appears above all to be a typical human being, an anti-hero full of contradictions, in whom we can all recognize ourselves.
Did Orwell build the world of the plot around this character, or did he adapt the character to the world around him? What is important here is to demonstrate the cohesion relationship between Winston’s characterization and the specifics of the world of the plot.
At the beginning of the novel, Winston is not a dissident or an ideologue, he has not yet joined the Brotherhood, that obscure group of renegades which, it will turn out, is nothing more than a fabrication of the regime in place. Winston behaves like any other person with full human faculties, that is to say, he…
…thinks,
…complains without acting,
…gives free rein to his curiosity,
and to his desires,
… wonders about his identity and his roots,
… is aware of his own death,
… cheats,
… suffers.
The problem is that none of these traits are legitimate or acceptable in “Big Brother’s” world and each is liable to be heavily punished in defiance of any notion of proportionality.
The type of cohesion that binds the two worlds, the plot and the protagonist, is incompatibility.
Winston is a human being trapped in an environment that has nothing human about it and systematically works to eliminate any reflexes of his species.
It is this impossible coexistence that creates the main events of the plot and our empathy.
The contradictions between the character’s deep nature and his behaviors are the results of the influence of the environment, the slow contamination of the soul, the crushing of beings by an autocratic system.
Here are some examples of this characterization in cohesion/incompatibility type:
Characterization: Winston loves books, he is interested in language. He is a cultured intellectual who not only wants to understand the “how” but also the “why”
World of the plot: The Party imposes a new language (the Newspeak) obtained by simplifying English to the extreme and by taking advantage of the ambiguities thus obtained to instrument the reasoning faculties of the speakers. There are no laws in Oceania. The power in place is not legitimized, the citizens are kept in the dark about the values of the society (the “why”)
Contradictions: Winston takes a keen interest in Newspeak and practices it despite its inherently simplistic and manipulative nature. He even befriends one of its designers.
Characterization: Winston often thinks and talks about the past. He is nostalgic for the London of his childhood. He goes to a flea market to buy old things. When his lover, Julia, asks him what an object he has bought is for, he replies:
‘I don’t think it’s anything—I mean, I don’t think it was ever put to any use. That’s what I like about it. It’s a little chunk of history that they’ve forgotten to alter. It’s a message from a hundred years ago, if one knew how to read it.’
He investigates an old article in the Times that provides evidence of the falsification of past events by the ruling power and the fabrication of the crimes of which a group of former Party members who have become dissidents had been accused.
The world of the plot: The past is strictly rewritten to serve the theses of the repressive policy of the ruling party.
Contradictions: Winston, who says he loves his job, participates in the corruption of memory: his task is to rewrite the archives of the official newspaper, The Times, and to throw the originals into a furnace.
Characterization: Winston writes his diary in an old notebook, with a pen (so as not to scratch the paper with a pen…)
The world of the plot: The citizens are satisfied with the information broadcasted by the “telescreens”, the books are forbidden or created by machines, the writings which are used by the power are locked in forbidden archives. Winston uses a machine, the “speakwrite”, and only rarely writes notes.
Contradictions: Winston throws the original Times into a hole called “The Memory Hole”.
Characterization: Winston is sensitive to poetry. He is touched by a nursery rhyme his grandfather told him when he was a boy.
The world of the plot: The telescreen shows reports of military events, the results of five-year plans, propaganda speeches, slogans, military music all day long… Winston says he has never heard a party member sing.
Contradictions: Winston finds pleasing to the ear a “distressing” popular refrain “composed out of all human intervention by an apparatus, the versifier.”
“Characterization”: Winston is moved by certain landscapes, nature, birdsong. He dreams of the “Golden Land”, a sunny pasture where he meets a brunette who has a “splendid” gesture capable of annihilating Big Brother
The world of the plot: In the urban landscape “all color has receded except that of the posters posted everywhere”. Police helicopters fly over London.
Were there always these vistas of rotting nineteenth-century houses, their sides shored up with baulks of timber, their windows patched with cardboard and their roofs with corrugated iron, their crazy garden walls sagging in all directions?
Characterization: Winston is in physical pain (back, varicose ulcer). He has five false teeth. He has a phobia of rats. He has strong inner emotions (anger, sadness, joy).
And what he wanted, more even than to be loved, was to break down that wall of virtue, even if it were only once in his whole life
The world of the plot: The expression of emotions, considered unproductive weaknesses, is forbidden.
Not to let one’s feelings appear in one’s face was a habit that had acquired the status of an instinct…
The Thought Police take suspects to Room 101 to torture them by confronting them with their phobias.
Contradictions: Winston participates in the “two minutes of hate” session, in which everyone must express, loud and clear, their hatred of the enemies of the people:
In a lucid moment Winston found that he was shouting with the others and kicking his heel violently against the rung of his chair.
He confesses to his lover that he wanted to push his wife off a cliff, but that he gave up ” – So why do you regret not having done it?
Only because I prefer a positive to a negative.
He has integrated, despite everything, the rhetoric of emotional negativity disseminated by the political system.
Characterization: Winston accepts his sexual desires. He explains that he has resented his wife’s physical reticence and anti-sex ideology.
She would lie there with shut eyes, neither resisting nor co-operating but SUBMITTING.
He has sex with a prostitute despite the risks involved, her advanced age and her toothless mouth.
The world of the plot: The goal of the government of Oceania is to prevent men and women from forming alliances that would escape its control and to empty the sexual act of all pleasure. Marriages must be approved by the Party and will be refused if based on physical attraction. The “Antisexual Youth” advocate absolute chastity and artificial insemination. Sexual drive is considered a waste of energy and a danger to the Party.
Contradictions: Winston says he could have lived with his wife “on the condition that they agreed to remain chaste,” but it is she who, despite her sexual block, insisted that they continue to try to “make a child.” Winston is a misogynist. He does not trust women because he is convinced that they are the most faithful guardians of the Party’s theses.
Characterization: Winston lives alone and enjoys the solitude that allows him to think and write in his diary.
The world of the plot: The culture of the regime has made community activities, discussion groups, political conferences, group gymnastics mandatory.
Contradictions: As he the evening at the Community Center “His soul writhed with boredom, but for once he had had no impulse to shirk his evening at the Centre…” Winston comes to appreciate the security of conformity.
Characterization: Winston is fatalistic. He believes that he will not be able to escape the Thought Police and that he will be “evaporated” like all the others before him. He believes his death is imminent.
The world of the plot: The belief that something can go wrong goes against optimism, the supreme value erected by the Party.
Contradictions: It is the predicted and inevitable outcome that motivates Winston to take atypical risks.
Now he had recognized himself as a dead man it became important to stay alive as long as possible.
Characterization: Winston makes assumptions based on mere appearances (O’Brien’s behavior leads him to believe he is a rebel).
But at any rate he had the appearance of being a person that you could talk to if somehow you could cheat the telescreen and get him alone.
The world of the plot: Everyone is suspicious of everyone else. Even parents risk having their children turned over to the Thought Police for being unorthodox.
Contradictions: Winston doubts everyone except O’Brian, who will become his tormentor.
Characterization:Winston understands and appreciates the complexity of people (his ex-wife, his mother), their humanity buried under layers of indoctrination and despair.
Tragedy, he perceived, belonged to the ancient time, to a time when there was still privacy, love, and friendship, and when the members of a family stood by one another without needing to know the reason. His mother’s memory tore at his heart because she had died loving him, when he was too young and selfish to love her in return, and because somehow, he did not remember how, she had sacrificed herself to a conception of loyalty that was private and unalterable.
The world of the plot: The Party works to eliminate all complexity.
Today there were fear, hatred, and pain, but no dignity of emotion, no deep or complex sorrows.
It instills its precepts in children:
Nearly all children nowadays were horrible. What was worst of all was that by means of such organizations as the Spies they were systematically turned into ungovernable little savages, and yet this produced in them no tendency whatever to rebel against the discipline of the Party. On the contrary, they adored the Party and everything connected with it. The songs, the processions, the banners, the hiking, the drilling with dummy rifles, the yelling of slogans, the worship of Big Brother —it was all a sort of glorious game to them.
Contradictions: When Winston meets O’Brien, whom he believes to be one of the Brotherhood’s important figures, he swears that he is willing to commit any atrocity to serve the cause of the underground resistance movement: commit murder, sabotage that could result in the death of innocents, corrupt youth, distribute addictive drugs, encourage prostitution, and even throw vitriol in a child’s face.
In the name of love, freedom, and affirming his humanity, Winston is willing to use more or less the same weapons as his worst enemy.
If you can FEEL that staying human is worth while, even when it can’t have any result whatever, you’ve beaten them.’

