Les Misérables, “A Tempest in a Skull” Part 1, VII, 3 Victor Hugo, 1862.
An argumentation can influence the plot (=the choice of a new action) if the stakes and possible risks are concrete and generate strong emotions.
Jean Valjean, a former convict with a painful past, hides under the false identity of M. Madeleine, mayor of a small town. Inspector Javert arrives and tells him that a man suspected of being Jean Valjean, who is facing a heavy sentence, is about to go on trial. The protagonist is worked on by his conscience.
A Intrapersonal Event that Generates an Argumentation
The obstacle here is not the news reported by Javert, but the dilemma it provokes in the protagonist. M. Madeleine has to choose one and only one new objective, that is the conclusion of the argument. The arguments describe what would happen if the right decision was not made.
He hastily relighted his candle.
“Well, what then?” he said to himself; “what am I afraid of?
The argumentation is represented by three types of discourse:
– A soliloquy by the protagonist (verbal action),
– The protagonist’s thoughts, reported by an “extradiegetic” narrating agent with the power of “internal focalization”.
– The narrating agent’s argumentative comments.
This argumentation deals with the dilemma in which the protagonist finds himself (do nothing and let an innocent man be accused or denounce himself and lose his new identity). The stakes and risks factor is applied to the argumentation and its conclusion is that one of the stakes is more important than the others.
It is through a thorough argumentation that the protagonist, discreetly guided by the narrating agent, will manage to calm his conscience and, incidentally, get back to sleep.
It is argued that negative emotions can result from bad reasoning.
The argumentation begins with the protagonist’s thoughts and questions about the stakes and risks (factor) attached to his decision not to reveal his true identity (objective).
What is there in all that for me to think about? I am safe; all is over. I had but one partly open door through which my past might invade my life, and behold that door is walled up forever! That Javert, who has been annoying me so long; that terrible instinct which seemed to have divined me, which had divined me—good God! and which followed me everywhere; that frightful hunting-dog, always making a point at me, is thrown off the scent, engaged elsewhere, absolutely turned from the trail: henceforth he is satisfied; he will leave me in peace; he has his Jean Valjean. Who knows? it is even probable that he will wish to leave town! And all this has been brought about without any aid from me, and I count for nothing in it!
M. Madeleine wants to persuade himself that there is no longer any risk (Javert) or stake (his identity).
Ah! but where is the misfortune in this? Upon my honor, people would think, to see me, that some catastrophe had happened to me! After all, if it does bring harm to some one, that is not my fault in the least: it is Providence which has done it all; it is because it wishes it so to be, evidently. Have I the right to disarrange what it has arranged? What do I ask now? Why should I meddle? It does not concern me;
He also wants to claim that no dilemma can exist in the face of “providence” (first moral argument).
what! I am not satisfied: but what more do I want? The goal to which I have aspired for so many years, the dream of my nights, the object of my prayers to Heaven,—security,—I have now attained; it is God who wills it; I can do nothing against the will of God, and why does God will it? In order that I may continue what I have begun, that I may do good, that I may one day be a grand and encouraging example, that it may be said at last, that a little happiness has been attached to the penance which I have undergone, and to that virtue to which I have returned. Really, I do not understand why I was afraid, a little while ago, to enter the house of that good curé, and to ask his advice; this is evidently what he would have said to me: It is settled; let things take their course; let the good God do as he likes!”
M. Madeleine believes he has discovered a divine mission, a good that would erase an evil, in the direction of which he has not yet dared to look.
The narrating agent enters the scene and expresses a barely concealed opinion on Madeleine’s convictions through a metaphor:
Thus did he address himself in the depths of his own conscience, bending over what may be called his own abyss; he rose from his chair, and began to pace the room: “Come,” said he, “let us think no more about it; my resolve is taken!”…
The protagonist sets himself a new objective, immediately thwarted by a new obstacle.
… but he felt no joy.
Quite the reverse
Before continuing the journey, the narrating agent allows himself a comment on this obstacle, tinged with a moral argument.
One can no more prevent thought from recurring to an idea than one can the sea from returning to the shore: the sailor calls it the tide; the guilty man calls it remorse; God upheaves the soul as he does the ocean.
Then he describes the protagonist’s suffering (compares it to a “Stations of the Cross”), which Mr. Madeleine cannot himself describe yet. Does the narrating agent increasingly express his personal opinion in this deliberation, or does he merely report the protagonist’s thoughts?
After the expiration of a few moments, do what he would, he resumed the gloomy dialogue in which it was he who spoke and he who listened, saying that which he would have preferred to ignore, and listened to that which he would have preferred not to hear, yielding to that mysterious power which said to him: “Think!” as it said to another condemned man, two thousand years ago, “March on!”
The narrating agent opens a new parenthesis, gives his opinion on the habit of soliloquy, and also mentions his own narrative (“metalepsis”). He states the ultimate objective that the protagonist has refused to consider until now and unambiguously sets himself up as a stakeholder in this deliberation:
Before proceeding further, and in order to make ourselves fully understood, let us insist upon one necessary observation. It is certain that people do talk to themselves; there is no living being who has not done it. It may even be said that the word is never a more magnificent mystery than when it goes from thought to conscience within a man, and when it returns from conscience to thought; it is in this sense only that the words so often employed in this chapter, he said, he exclaimed, must be understood; one speaks to one’s self, talks to one’s self, exclaims to one’s self without breaking the external silence; there is a great tumult; everything about us talks except the mouth. The realities of the soul are nonetheless realities because they are not visible and palpable.
So he asked himself where he stood. He interrogated himself upon that “settled resolve.” He confessed to himself that all that he had just arranged in his mind was monstrous, that “to let things take their course, to let the good God do as he liked,” was simply horrible; to allow this error of fate and of men to be carried out, not to hinder it, to lend himself to it through his silence, to do nothing, in short, was to do everything! that this was hypocritical baseness in the last degree! that it was a base, cowardly, sneaking, abject, hideous crime!
The narrating agent adds a layer to the weight of the dilemma felt by the protagonist.
For the first time in eight years, the wretched man had just tasted the bitter savor of an evil thought and of an evil action.
He spit it out with disgust.
This passage is the heart of the argumentation in which the main arguments are expressed. The line between Mr. Madeleine’s conscience and the narrating agent’s opinions is blurred.
He continued to question himself. He asked himself severely what he had meant by this, “My object is attained!” He declared to himself that his life really had an object; but what object? To conceal his name? To deceive the police? Was it for so petty a thing that he had done all that he had done? Had he not another and a grand object, which was the true one to save, not his person, but his soul; to become honest and good once more; to be a just man? Was it not that above all, that alone, which he had always desired, which the Bishop had enjoined upon him—to shut the door on his past? But he was not shutting it! great God! he was re-opening it by committing an infamous action! He was becoming a thief once more, and the most odious of thieves! He was robbing another of his existence, his life, his peace, his place in the sunshine. He was becoming an assassin. He was murdering, morally murdering, a wretched man. He was inflicting on him that frightful living death, that death beneath the open sky, which is called the galleys. On the other hand, to surrender himself to save that man, struck down with so melancholy an error, to resume his own name, to become once more, out of duty, the convict Jean Valjean, that was, in truth, to achieve his resurrection, and to close forever that hell whence he had just emerged; to fall back there in appearance was to escape from it in reality. This must be done! He had done nothing if he did not do all this; his whole life was useless; all his penitence was wasted. There was no longer any need of saying, “What is the use?” He felt that the Bishop was there, that the Bishop was present all theNoble Objects 236 more because he was dead, that the Bishop was gazing fixedly at him, that henceforth Mayor Madeleine, with all his virtues, would be abominable to him, and that the convict Jean Valjean would be pure and admirable in his sight; that men beheld his mask, but that the Bishop saw his face; that men saw his life, but that the Bishop beheld his conscience.
The episode ends with the description of the new objective, which follows from the conclusion of the argumentation: The most important thing is to save one’s soul, the only stake of value.
So he must go to Arras, deliver the false Jean Valjean, and denounce the real one. Alas! that was the greatest of sacrifices,the most poignant of victories, the last step to take; but it must be done. Sad fate! he would enter into sanctity only in the eyes of God when he returned to infamy in the eyes of men.
“Well,” said he, “let us decide upon this; let us do our duty; let us save this man.” He uttered these words aloud, without perceiving that he was speaking aloud.
The conclusion is so important that for the first time “the mouth speaks”. The reality of the soul becomes palpable.
Deliberation, which precedes the conclusion of an argumentation, a decision or an action, makes it possible to involve the receiving agent in the process of logical analysis of the different arguments and to make them participate in the emotional torments of a dilemma.
In summary:
► The narrating agent (“implied author” Victor Hugo?) wanted to test the solidity of the basis of his protagonist’s redemption, and by the same token, indirectly, give us his definition of the ‘moral being’.
► He confronts his protagonist with a functional obstacle, Jean-Valjean is partly responsible for the arrest of an innocent man.
► The choice of the next action involves having to decide between two equally negative consequences (dilemma).
► The protagonist learns to recognize the superiority of reasoning (analysis of stakes and risks) over emotions.

