Select Page

Revealing the feelings of a character by having them ask contradictory questions

Certain terms are unique to this website. You can find their definitions in the glossary.

A question can be a verbal action that serves a specific function for the person who asks it.

In 1930s California, George and his protégé Lennie work as ranch hands. Lennie, a naïve and sometimes impulsive colossus, dreams of tending the rabbits on the farm George says he wants to buy.

Chapter four of the book deals with Lennie’s visit to the stable, where Crooks, the groom, the only African-American worker on the ranch, lives.

Crooks, haughty, proud, and determined to keep his distance from everyone – a way for him to get back at the segregation he is subjected to on a daily basis – reproaches Lennie for barging into his little room located in the stable, a quasi-criminal intrusion into his own little world. But Lennie just wants to talk about the little puppy he just got and his farm project.

Crooks reluctantly listens to him and then starts to ask him a question that destabilizes him.

You travel aroun’ with George, don’t ya?” “Sure. Me an’ him goes ever’ place together.” Crooks continued. “Sometimes he talks, and you don’t know what the hell he’s talkin’ about. Ain’t that so?

Why does Crooks express doubt about the communication between Lennie and George? What might be the purpose of this verbal action?

Crooks may simply want to inquire about Lennie and George’s relationship, or he may be making fun of him.

Jus’ nuts,” said Crooks. “I don’t blame the guy you travel with for keepin’ you outa sight.

Crooks insists.

“Jus’ talks on, an’ you don’t know what the hell it’s all about?”

And then suddenly, unexpectedly, the stable groom starts talking about his own childhood:

I ain’t a Southern Negro,” he said.” I was born right bere in California. My old man had a chicken ranch, ’bout ten acres. The white kids come to play at our place, an’ sometimes I event to play with them, and some of them was pretty nice. My of man didn’t like that. I never knew till long later why he didn’t like that. But I know now.

We now understand that behind Crooks’ words lies a purpose that has nothing to do with Lennie or his relationship with George.

By casting doubt on George’s dream, and even going so far as to suggest to Lennie that George might one day, out of the blue, let him down, Crooks is indirectly speaking to us about his own feelings of marginalization, loneliness, lack of communication, consequences of the stigma he has been subjected to.

In Crooks’ eyes, Lennie cannot understand what George is saying to him, because in his world no one talks to each other, no one talks to him. His objective is to convince himself that he is not the only one who feels rejected and isolated.

This verbal action is consistent with what Lennie has just said about his relationship with George. It contradicts what Lennie firmly believes: when George talks to him, especially about their future farm, he understands him perfectly.

With this verbal action, Crook tries to establish a codependent relationship between Lennie and himself. He wants him to be a victim of indifference and social exclusion like himself.

About this website   »