The Plausibility Factor
There are believable worlds and behaviours and others that are implausible (one of the possible causes of the breech of the narrative pact). It is possible to believe in an unreal world or a non-standard behaviour, providing that it is plausible.
A world or reality is plausible when it’s ‘viable’.
To be ‘viable’, these entities must be composed of interdependent elements that participate in the realization of their functions, in accordance with their values.
This “interdependence” is most often achieved through a cause-and-effect connection (cohesion factor).
To be able to identify what has caused a particular effect is to understand the functioning of a world, which is the guarantee of its plausibility. Even if it is not real, a world that generates at least one consistent, predictable, specific effect, consistent with at least one value, is a credible world.
* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.
Narrative pact
Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.
»
Cognitive experience
Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.
»
Emotional experience
Probe and share all kind of emotions.
»
Key Points:
-
Plausibility lies somewhere between belief and disbelief
The impression of a ‘viable’ reality is dependent on common sense, which is impossible to define precisely.
But it can be argued that the logic that binds together the constituents of a world must be rational and consistent for that world to be/appear plausible.
For more on logic.
-
Characters in fictional worlds (plot, characters, narrating agent’s worlds) make the same distinction between what is true or false, real or unreal, as we do in our own (real) world.
Their criteria (logic) must be defined and transmitted to the receiving agent, otherwise the fictional world is surreal (Le chien andalou by L. Buñuel and S. Dali).
The plausibility criteria of a character’s world may be different from the criteria of the world in which that character lives (e.g. An adult character believing in the “reality” of Father Christmas…).
The plausibility of the plot depends mainly on the consistency of the ‘characterisation’ and also on the credibility of the obstacles set up by the narrating agent.
-
Plausibility is the creative heart of a narrative
This is a factor that gives the narrating agent the possibility to push the limits of the logic of the plot and its sometimes limiting realism, which is the essence of the creative act: to come up with something that did not exist before.
The narrating agent may choose to distort the reality of the world of the plot during the process of creating the narrative in order to support their point of view, to reinforce a stylistic effect, to maintain curiosity, to evoke a particular emotion, to create “a good scene”, etc.
The boundary between the realism of the world of the plot and the artificiality of events can therefore be porous (“poetic licence”).
-
Willing suspension of disbelief
In the event of a breach of the narrative pact due to implausibility, the receiving agent is willing to give the narrating agent a “second chance” in order to perpetuate, if possible (at all costs?), the magical link that binds them to the narrative. This decision is called the “suspension of disbelief”. It is earned by openly acknowledging the implausibility of a fact, an action or an argument: “You won’t believe it, but…”
Avenues for reflections and resources
»
Ask your questions,
have your say
»
