The Cohesion Factor
Cohesion occurs when the effects and interpretation of the meaning of the use of a tool* or object* depend on the use of one or more other tool(s) or object(s).
This factor creates a logical and meaningful connection that conglomerates the components of a narrative.
*Objects = word, sentence, paragraph, chapter, sequence, scene, act, image, shot, light, sound, space, colour, volume…
* Tools = Event, ‘characterisation’, world, point of view, ‘focalization’, genre convention, narrating agent’s time, verbal action, ending.
* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.
Narrative pact
Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.
»
Cognitive experience
Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.
»
Emotional experience
Probe and share all kind of emotions.
»
Key Points:
-
The Cohesion factor can be applied to two types of narrative tools or objects:
1. The ones that are essential for understanding the plot. These are the protagonists, characters, events and situations leading directly to these events (the narrating agent can make a coherent choice of obstacles).
2. The tools and objects that are essential for understanding the intentions of the narrating agent and the purposes of the narrative (scenes, arguments, comments, points of view, stylistic elements).
• Accessory elements are not essential to the understanding of the plot (incoherence), but ideally contribute to the understanding of the narrative
Any narrative tool or object is eligible to be accessory, including narrative knots that are not necessary for the understanding of the narrative. They are sometimes called “anecdotal details”, “parasitic elements”, “flourish”, “lyrical or stylistic flights”, “language games”, “beautiful imagery”, etc.
Accessory elements give the narrating agent the opportunity to give free rein to their subjectivity, to bypass the “tyranny” of the plot, to transgress narrative conventions, to escape significance.
-
Cohesion, or its absence, can be part of a narrative strategy
The choice of cohesion or incoherence (e.g. accessory elements, “alterity”) can be an important facet of the narrating agent’s strategy to reinforce a point of view (rhetorical support), establish a hierarchy of events, communicate a mood, or enhance the impact of a narrative.
The function of accessory elements can be to express the absurdity of their uselessness. They are rife in comedies where telling a plot is less important than making the most of every comic situation.
The introduction of accessory elements into a narrative by an ‘unreliable’ narrating agent may betray their desire to divert our attention from meaningful and relevant narrative knots.
-
Order, a classification that obeys one or more criteria, rule(s) or convention(s), is a criteria of cohesion, i.e. it has (ideally) a purpose
In a narrative it governs the choice of what comes first (object A) and what comes immediately after (object B), which can also be called editing.
Order also refers to a specific relationship between an object and a whole (e.g. the citizen of a country).
There is no rule that prescribes or prohibits the use of order.
-
Cohesion can become counterproductive
Too much cohesion or too many significant connections can lead to didactic heaviness, to the impression that the receiving agent’s work has been made a little too easy for them.
-
Used as an aesthetic gimmick, chaos is recognizable by its lack of specific contribution to the narrative (surprise, stakes-risks, suspense, subtext, mystery, etc.)
Or it is used (most often through the use of “flashback”) as a simple transmission of information necessary to understand the plot.
-
In writing, the present tense (verbal tense) can be temporarily extracted from the temporal space of the events of the plot by commenting on them (present general truth)
“And meanwhile, the earth revolves around the sun.”
-
Cinema and theatre give us the impression of simultaneity (= cohesion factor) of the events of the plot and their narrative
But this is only an impression, because a narrative always takes place after the events it represents (sometimes only a fraction of a second later, when the narrating agent is a commentator witnessing events taking place before their eyes).
-
The receiving agent makes assumptions about the chronological order of the different parts (scenes, situations)
In the case where the narrative does not follow the timeline of the situations, it is necessary to manage the natural and instinctive propensity of the receiving agent to “structure” the work (ensure its cohesion) by assuming that a certain moment follows the previous one and is the continuation or consequence of it.
-
Interpretation: Three types of receiving agent, one cohesion
1. Some of the receiving agents take full ownership of the narrative. They tear it apart, reconstruct it, adapt it, conform it to their subjectivity, and make it their own by seeing, hearing and understanding what they and they alone hear, see and understand.
2. Other receiving agents put the narrative through the sieve of their specific expertise, which they consider to be ‘objective’ (human sciences, political or literary theories, particular skills, etc.) and see in it intentions that the narrating agent never had, or even refutes a posteriori.
3. The third group manages to recognize and interpret a specific intention, consciously and intentionally transmitted by the narrating agent. It is this material that is covered by the term cohesion.
-
Mind-bending montages incite us to reflect on our own conception of reality
There are structures that do not take into account (temporarily or permanently) either the cause-and-effect relationship, the chronological order of the reported facts and events, or any of the pragmatic structural patterns (industry standards).
For a list of cohesion criteria:
Cohesion factor
Cohesion types
»
Avenues for reflections and resources
»
Ask your questions,
have your say
»
