Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck, 1937
The central objective of the plot may not be achieved in the end.
The protagonist may decide on a new objective. The pursuit of the latter generates a final event whose surprise initiates the questioning that opens the way to the meaning (real or perceived) of the work.
SPOILER ALERT!
George and Lennie, two itinerant farm workers in Depression-era California, will never realize their plan. They will not be able to work long enough on the farm that employs them to buy that little farm they so desperately want.
Lennie’s impulsive nature causes the irreparable breach. The wife of the boss’s son cannot resist his destructive grip. The giant, who has no intention of causing harm, cannot control his strength. It is an accident caused by a misunderstanding.
But it is nonetheless an accident that had every chance of happening one day or another. George’s error is to have ignored its predictability.
“I should of knew,” George said hopelessly. “I guess maybe way back in my head I did.”
So, to bring the plot to a resolution, the “implicit author” chooses to confront the protagonist with an obstacle that is part of the logical, or at least plausible, evolution of Lennie’s behavior (something very serious will/must happen one day).
The reaction to this interpersonal event brings about the resolution of the plot – and in the case of Steinbeck’s novel, the end of the narrative, bar a few lines.
After the discovery of the lifeless body of Curley’s wife, George decides that their plan for independence is unfeasible without Lennie, despite the insistence of Candy, whose financial contribution is far from negligible. George now sees himself conforming to the fate of the common laborer: work for fifty dollars a month, spend it in the bars of the city in one weekend and start again the next month.
George then briefly explores his options: maybe Lennie could be hospitalized? Maybe he could convince Curley and Carlson not to shoot him?
But he comes to a conclusion that motivates his decision, the objective of the final plot event.
Carlson announces that his Luger gun is missing. We understand that George probably stole it when he returned to his room before Candy told the workers that Curley’s wife was dead.
Has George decided at this point to kill Lennie or is he still thinking of escaping with him and using the gun to facilitate their escape? (retention/mystery factor)
His intention becomes clear after he joins Lennie by the river, their rallying point in case of trouble.
First George tells Lennie that he doesn’t want to blame him anymore. Lennie threatens to go live in a cave, as if the lack of acrimony makes their relationship impossible. George tells him that he wants him to stay and once again indulges in the chanting that Lennie is so fond of (and so is George, but without admitting it).
“We gonna get a little place,” George began. He reached in his side pocket and brought out Carlson’s Luger;
George’s intentions are now abundantly clear. His objective (to shoot his friend himself) provokes a shock (surprise), caused by the application of the cohesion factor to this end.
The objective and the action that follows are in complete contradiction with what we know of the relationship between the two men.
The surprise is prolonged by George’s hesitation, an inner conflict (intrapersonal). Perhaps he will not find within himself the strength to carry out the task he believes to be indispensable?
George raised the gun and his hands shook, and he dropped his hand to the ground again.
After another mention of their plan to buy a farm, George, despite the violent tremor that agitates his hand, shoots Lennie in the back of the head.
The surprise of the realization of an objective (killing Lennie) that is the opposite of the central objective of the plot (living together on a farm) provokes an instant emotional reaction in the receiving agent (it is the end of a friendship, someone “different”, an outsider, is rejected by society, etc.).
But this surprise goes much further than a simple sensation.
It initiates a questioning, a reflection on the part of the receiving agent as to George’s motivation, the relevance of his gesture, its moral dimensions, etc. which gives its value, its reason to be the ultimate plot twist.

