Nineteen Eighty-four (1984), George Orwell, 1946, Secker & Warburg
The illogical behavior of a protagonist is plausible if it contributes to the identity of the world in which they belong.
The world of the plot of George Orwell’s novel, published in 1946, is that of a fictional society set in 1984, regulated by an authoritarian, omnipotent and bellicose government. Freedom of expression is abolished, citizens are spied on around the clock, personal thoughts are systematically censored, and fierce repression, suspicion and fear reign in the workplace, in the home and in leisure.
One of the questions that naturally arises is the viability of this world: how can it be acceptable/supportable – willingly or unwillingly – to its inhabitants?
The protagonist, Winston Smith, is a civil servant whose job it is to suppress newspaper articles and rewrite history in favor of the current regime. Despite this, Winston rejects the world to which he belongs. He is outraged by the abuses of his government, consciously describes and analyzes the workings of the systemic tyranny, and dreams of independence and justice.
Like all his colleagues, he must participate once a day in a film session during which images of emblematic enemies of the regime (notably the traitor Goldstein, a former member of the Party) and their violent annihilation by his soldiers are shown.
This gathering, called “The Two Minutes of Hatred”, reveals a collective emotions world, the state of mind, at a given moment, of a group of characters.
People were leaping up and down in their places and shouting at the tops of their voices in an effort to drown the maddening bleating voice that came from the screen. The little sandy-haired woman had turned bright pink, and her mouth was opening and shutting like that of a landed fish. Even O’Brien’s heavy face was flushed. He was sitting very straight in his chair, his powerful chest swelling and quivering as though he were standing up to the assault of a wave. The dark-haired girl behind Winston had begun crying out ‘Swine! Swine! Swine!’ and suddenly she picked up a heavy Newspeak dictionary and flung it at the screen. It struck Goldstein’s nose and bounced off; the voice continued inexorably. In a lucid moment Winston found that he was shouting with the others and kicking his heel violently against the rung of his chair.
Winston, whose dissenting opinions, humanistic thoughts, and poetic sensibility have been presented earlier in the narrative, should, here, according to the principle of consistent “characterization” reject this regressive and undignified event. Instead, the opposite proves to be true.
The horrible thing about the Two Minutes Hate was not that one was obliged to act a part, but, on the contrary, that it was impossible to avoid joining in. Within thirty seconds any pretence was always unnecessary. A hideous ecstasy of fear and vindictiveness, a desire to kill, to torture, to smash faces in with a sledgehammer, seemed to flow through the whole group of people like an electric current, turning one even against one’s will into a grimacing, screaming lunatic.
In a world where all emotion is suppressed, controlled or repressed, the possibility of lifting this ban for a brief moment violently releases the most primitive impulses.
Even Winston’s feelings of love for a fellow member of a righteous youth group are perverted by the surrounding madness.
Vivid, beautiful hallucinations flashed through his mind. He would flog her to death with a rubber truncheon. He would tie her naked to a stake and shoot her full of arrows like Saint Sebastian. He would ravish her and cut her throat at the moment of climax. Better than before, moreover, he realized WHY it was that he hated her. He hated her because she was young and pretty and sexless, because he wanted to go to bed with her and would never do so, because round her sweet supple waist, which seemed to ask you to encircle it with your arm, there was only the odious scarlet sash, aggressive symbol of chastity.
His reactions, which are “not like him”, are nevertheless plausible, because they are part of a specific situation. The emotional space of the group during these two minutes short-circuits Winston’s inner world and produces contradictory and destabilizing feelings. We have all seen, at one time or another, the influence that a group (peers, colleagues, crowd…) has had on our own behavior.
In addition to the conditions external to the protagonist, the latter (through the narrating agent capable of internal focalization) becomes aware of the incoherence of his reaction and analyzes the mechanism of it
And yet the rage that one felt was an abstract, undirected emotion which could be switched from one object to another like the flame of a blowlamp. Thus, at one moment Winston’s hatred was not turned against Goldstein at all, but, on the contrary, against Big Brother, the Party, and the Thought Police; and at such moments his heart went out to the lonely, derided heretic on the screen, sole guardian of truth and sanity in a world of lies. And yet the very next instant he was at one with the people about him, and all that was said of Goldstein seemed to him to be true. At those moments his secret loathing of Big Brother changed into adoration, and Big Brother seemed to tower up, an invincible, fearless protector, standing like a rock against the hordes of Asia, and Goldstein, in spite of his isolation, his helplessness, and the doubt that hung about his very existence, seemed like some sinister enchanter, capable by the mere power of his voice of wrecking the structure of civilization.
It is thus the combination of a specific situation (The Party channels the emotions of its subjects by offering them a cathartic outlet to make the world it has created “viable”) and an awareness of its own illogicality (“suspension of disbelief”), which makes the aberrant behavior of the protagonist plausible.

