The contributions of the narrating agent
1. The Heart of the Plot
The narrating agent conceives the elements constituting the plot’s central event – for narratives centered on at least one main plot – or the elements of a key event for chronicle-type narratives
A plot (or an event) revolves around an initial explicit objective and one or more direct or indirect obstacles: The protagonist wants something while risking getting something else…
Examples:
– Casablanca (film 1942) The protagonist declares that he wants to stay out of other people’s problems, that he doesn’t want to take sides (“I stick my neck out for nobody”).
– The Man with the Golden Arm (film 1955) The protagonist wants to beat his drug addiction.
– Cinderella (the original fairy tale) A poor young woman wishes she could marry a prince… but since the dawn of time, young people have been subject to the harsh laws of social class…
2. First “characterization” traits and outline of the world of the plot
The narrating agent chooses one or more protagonists, one or more worlds compatible with the plot and likely to enrich it by generating interesting / revealing / mysterious obstacles.
Narrative factors can already be applied to these two tools.
Examples:
– Casablanca: Rick, a former member of the international brigades (stakes-risks factor), runs a café in 1941 Casablanca, a place beset with illegal activities (cohesion/contradiction factor).
– The Man with the Golden Arm: Frankie, a drug-addicted ex-con (stakes-risk factor), lives in a rough neighborhood on Chicago’s north side (stakes-risk factor).
– Cinderella (Rhodopis, told by the geographer Strabo between 7 BC and 23): A young female slave wants to get out of her bath, but an eagle steals one of her sandals… and drops it on a king (cohesion/contrast factor)
3. The natural development of the initial situation
There are developments that follow logically from the heart of the plot; they are predictable, expected, even obligatory (realism, plausibility). They are not generated by the narrating agent’s imagination alone but derive from the logic called for by the objective and the foreseeable, plausible obstacles.
The narrating agent chooses those that are most significant to them. This choice gives specific meaning to a narrative.
The narrative factors most often applied at this stage are realism, plausibility, stakes-risks, typification.
Examples:
– Casablanca: Rick is involved against his will, his moral compass is tested, he risks losing his café, he must choose sides.
– The Man with the Golden Arm: Frankie relapses, his old life catches up with him, he can’t get hired as a musician, he may or may not be able to overcome his addiction.
– Cinderella: The king seeks out the owner of the sandal and marries her…
4. Addition(s) to the initial situation
The narrating agent may ask whether the events directly generated by the heart of the plot need to be supplemented by other events arising from a change in the protagonist’s initial objective, or from the emergence of a new objective.
The situation given by the heart of the plot is thus revived by one or more “twists”, which redirect the protagonist’s objective or cause him to change his strategy.
Examples:
– Casablanca: Rick doesn’t just want to remain neutral; he has to deal with the unexpected arrival of a former lover.
– The Man with the Golden Arm: Frankie must go back to work for his old boss as a croupier, if he’s to make it to his meeting with the agent who can get him a job as a jazz musician.
– Cinderella (Aspasia the Phocaean, 2nd century AD): The protagonist, raised by her father following the death of her mother, dreams of a dove who transforms into a woman. This fairy erases her physical flaws, which has an intoxicating effect on the Persian regent Cyrus the Younger, whom she meets at a banquet.
5. Collateral obstacles
The narrating agent confronts the protagonist with obstacles not directly opposed to the completion of the main objective(s), e.g. a love story, but chosen to satisfy, or counterbalance, the realism or plausibility of the plot, its world, the characterization of the protagonist, etc.
The most common narrative factors applied to these obstacles are realism, plausibility, intentionality, typification, cohesion.
These obstacles constitute a stage in the representation of the “opinion” (point of view) that the narrating agent has of the protagonist, and/or in the realization of one or more narrative functions:
• Narrative pact (intentionality, sincerity, plausibility, competence)
• Cognitive experience.
• Emotional experience
These obstacles help to build the “transaction” between the protagonist and the receiving agent, who agrees to believe in the imaginary construct that is the narrative work, fictional or otherwise, on the condition that the protagonist…
moves them,
impresses them,
makes them angry,
elicits pity,
amuses them,
frighten them,
intrigues them,
makes them think,
reminds them of someone,
reminds them of themselves,
encourages them to take an interest in their world, their way of thinking, their way of feeling,
Inspires them (frees their imagination),
etc.
Examples:
– Casablanca : Rick’s café can only stay open because he lets his friend, the corrupt Vichy police chief, win at roulette.
– The Man with the golden Arm : Frankie’s wife, who claims to be paralyzed following a car accident caused by her husband’s drunk driving, guilts him into staying with her.
– Cinderella: (The tale of Ye Xian, in: Miscellaneous Morsels from Youyang, Duan Chengshi, circa 860 A.D.) The orphaned protagonist is saddled with a stepmother and stepsisters who are mean to her. The bones of a magic fish provide her with clothes and a golden shoe, which she loses at a local fair. The shoe ends up in the hands of a king…
6. The narrative
This is the second stage in the “representation” of the narrating agent’s point of view: the selection of factors, which are applied to the narrative tools when the plot is narrated.
This stage completes the “transaction” between the narrating agent and the receiving agent: the latter trusts the former on the condition that they are able to answer these questions:
• What does the narrating agent want?
• Who is behind the narrative ?
• What is the narrating agent’s personal contribution to the plot?
• What are they trying to tell me? And why?
• What place have I been given in the narrative process (e.g. the ability to enter the inner world of the characters)?
A narrating agent might want to:
Demonstrate a particular gift (ideas, sensitivity, knowledge, etc.)
Be the center of interest
Fight or thwart the receiving agent’s expectations
Hide from reality
Be stuck in reality
Seek to penetrate the inner, secret world of the characters
Be overwhelmed by their plot/narrative
Be overwhelmed by the fight against their own plot/narrative.
Etc.
Another example
The narrating agent in Cyrano de Bergerac
Click here to
Continue the creation of the narrative
