Select Page

The Sincerity Factor

Sincerity, or authenticity, is generally defined as a matching of real intentions and feelings with words or actions.

This factor, applied to narrative tools, sanctions the intentions of the narrating agent: Are they telling the truth? Do they really mean what they wrote/said/shown to us? Are they doing their utmost to convey their narrative to us?

Examples of the use of the Sincerity to fulfil a specific narrative function* :

* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.

Sincerity

Narrative pact

Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.

»

Sincerity

Cognitive experience

Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.

»

Sincerity

Emotional experience

Probe and share all kind of emotions.

»

Key Points:

  • Sincerity in art is a controversial notion

It brings together moral, philosophical and psychological concepts, sometimes contradictory, partial, almost always subjective.

Sincerity is largely dependent on the paradigm of truth (towards others and towards oneself).

  • The narrating agent is put on the spot

Their truthfulness is enhanced if they openly admit the possibility that their truth may be subjective, not in accordance with reality, partially revealed, or part of a multiple reality.

The revelation of a truth involving possible negative consequences for the narrating agent, a risk, is another guarantee of sincerity.

Sincerity may be merely a means to the end of a ‘higher’ goal (e.g. André Gide’s desire for spiritual penance, his refusal to defend himself).

  • But in the artistic field, the notion of truth is not only about content, but also about form (style) and even about the personality of the narrating agent, which manifests itself in the way they approach their subject and use the narrative tools

The personality of the “implied author” sheds light on the content and form, which is essential to their attractiveness.

Sincerity is therefore not only a state of mind of the creator but also an ethic of choice and use of narrative tools comparable to the values associated with craftsmanship: economy of means, respect for the material, elegance of processes, rigour, the tool as an extension of the body, etc.

Style, the product of work, is somewhere between transparency (sincerity) and mannerism (artifice).

  • The narrative agent can be reticent to express themselves through their narrative

Despite narrative skills and savoir faire, the work remains opaque and distant. The capacities for astonishment and enjoyment of its narrating agent are not called upon. There is no “urgency” to the telling. Ideas are heavily dependent on social norms and conventions, on parental injunctions. The narrating agent has not been able to/willing to release their creative ‘Child’ and the encounter is not with the receiving agent’s own ‘Child’. There is no permission to ‘play’. The narrative pact is at risk.

For Further Details on Sincerity:
Sincerity

Avenues for reflections and resources

»

Sincerity

Ask your questions,
have your say

»