Select Page

The Retention Factor

Retention is applied when the narrating agent consciously or unconsciously withholds an element, temporarily, permanently or partially. This may be a component of the plot, the effects of a narrative tool, a part of a setting, a trait of a character, the identity of the narrating agent, a world, etc.

The receiving agent is immediately aware of the concealment or becomes aware later during the course of the narrative.

Examples of the use of the Retention to fulfil a specific narrative function* :

* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.

Retention

Narrative pact

Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.

»

Retention

Cognitive experience

Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.

»

Retention

Emotional experience

Probe and share all kind of emotions.

»

Key Points:

  • Withholding information can stimulate the imagination of the receiving agent or draw their attention in the narrative lacunae

Gaps guarantee a potentiality of meaning and can produce their own specific aesthetics.

But absence can also hide emptiness.

  • Retention is the essence of a narrative, which is itself a sophisticated strategy for delaying the revelation of the resolution of the central plot event

Mystery is both feared and expected by the receiving agent.

  • Narrative, as a product of selection, always involves a form of retention

It is therefore always relevant to ask what a narrative shouldn’t tell (cannot/will not tell or leaves ambiguous) in order to match the intentions of the narrating agent.

  • When the narrating agent is conscious of applying retention, the result is called mystery and generates the receiving agent’s curiosity and fear

Choosing to create and maintain mystery is a means by which the narrating agent can ‘steer’ the receiving agent’s interpretation of the narrative by possibly forcing them to construct hypotheses, fear an outcome or confront them with the meaninglessness or the ‘horrors’, of the unexplained or unexplainable.

A mystery that drags on can lose its emotional effectiveness and become a pure exercise in reasoning.

  • When there are doubts about the outcome of an action, this form of provisional retention of an expected (and necessarily known to the narrating agent) outcome is called suspense.

A simple mystery still triggers suspense, but its intensity is less, the duration of its effects is shorter than the effects of suspense fed by the constant contribution of hypotheses on the consequences of the actions (results), on the stakes and on the risks.

  • Suspense is concomitant, but not exclusively, to the surprise of the event / narrative knot.

The unknown, the unforeseen and the unpredictable always generate, to varying degrees, suspense (what will be the consequences of the situation created by the obstacle? What will happen next?)

  • Suspense implies the stretching of time, and therefore it is a form of slowing down the narrative (speed factor)

The narrating agent, for reasons of their own, feels that they must play on the receiving agent’s sense of uncertainty and anxiety. This effect is called a narrative tension.

  • A suspense that is too prolonged loses the full force of its effects and may betray the manipulative intentions of the narrating agent

… or the emptiness of the narrative.

  • The retention of information identifiable by the receiving agent is called “subtext”

It is implicit information.

The missing element is always factual.

For interpretations of ‘hidden’, ‘underhand’, implied meaning, etc. see the cohesion factor. 

  • When information is revealed to the receiving agent before the characters in the plot have access to it, or when only some of the characters have access to it, it is called “dramatic irony”

The term originated with the theatre and refers to one of the indirect effects of its fundamental principle, namely that characters come and go (drama = action) and are not necessarily aware of what has been said before they arrive on stage.

  • This form of retention raises questions about the consequences of knowing and not knowing, and the gap between appearances and reality

A distinction must be made between purely gratuitous and mocking irony and irony that carries a lesson, a truth (“The irony of fate…”).

  • There are sub-types of “dramatic irony”

– Verbal irony: when the receiving agent knows that a character is not saying what they think or are saying the opposite of what they think.

– Situational irony: when the receiving agent understands details of a situation that one or more of the characters does not.

– Socratic irony: when one character pretends to be ignorant in order to better attack the arguments of another.

– Various scams where one side is not informed of certain information (snowball system, boiler room, etc.)

  • The receiving agent may not be aware that the narrating agent has applied the retention factor

There are then three possibilities:

1. The withheld information is revealed later. The receiving agent discovers that something was kept secret. This revelation causes a surprise which directs the attention of the recipient of the narrative towards the intentions of the narrating agent, the use they make of their power over the receiving agent (cognitive experience).

2. Retention can turn into a mystery if the receiving agent discovers afterwards that important information has been withheld. This discovery can take place during the course of the narrative, at the end of it, or sometimes even much later (retrospectively).

3. The receiving agent is never aware of the existence of the concealed object. The narrating agent has fulfilled all the expectations of their receiving agent regarding the plot and its narration.

  • Narrative works use signs and images to convey a discourse, but their aim goes far beyond what is said and shown

Narrative works elicit representations that their recipients filter through their minds, their imaginations, their values, their ‘souls’.

For Further Details on Retention:
Retention

Avenues for reflections and resources

»

Retention

Ask your questions,
have your say

»