The narrative pact function*
*About the notion of function, click HERE
A narrative conforms, or does not conform, to numerous conventions and constraints (language, conditions of reception, laws of genre, etc.).
We are interested here in a contract of trust between the narrating agent and their receiving agent (reader, viewer, listener) which seems to me to take precedence over all other arrangements, explicit or not.
The terms of this narrative pact can be summarized as follows:
– The receiving agent is, in the first instance, willing to believe the narrating agent, this despite their “fictionalising” role (a narrative updates events, but also makes them potentially inaccurate).
– The receiving agent accepts the verisimilitude of fictional facts if they are compatible with the reality of the plot world: “diegetisation”.
– The narrating agent undertakes to maintain the belief of the receiving agent by making the world of the plot probable, logical and rational. This clause also applies to factual narratives, whose function is often the search for truth.
– The narrating agent assumes responsibility for the underlying intentions of the narrative, the explicit or implicit meaning derived from it (“content”, “message”, etc.) and the way in which they are transmitted to the recipient of the narrative (“form”, style, etc.): “Narrativisation”.
– For some narratives (cinema, TV, theatre) the audience wants to forget that “someone” chooses the location and movements of the camera, the various visual and sound effects, the interpretative points of view, and the editing cuts. The directors, actors, editors, etc. accept, willingly or unwillingly, to step aside, i.e. to make their interventions as transparent as possible. The fact remains that they are all narrating agents.
If this pact is broken, the receiving agent may reject the narrative and abandon their personal investment. More concretely, it is a book that falls out of the hands, a spectator who leaves the theater or changes channel, a character who believes that they are being told lies…
What factors* are applied to the narrative tools to ensure the observance of the pact?
*About the notion of factor, click HERE
There are two main reasons why we might disengage from a narrative work:
– The narrating agent “don’t know what they are talking about.”
– The narrating agent “don’t know how to narrate” (= narrative tools are not used or misused according to dominant aesthetic norms).
The competence factor
The narrating agent can convince us to believe in the reality of the world of the plot provided that we are able to understand the logic of the cause-effect relationship of the occurrences (with the exception of specifically illogical and surreal worlds).
The plausibility factor
If the work does not do what it announces, explicitly or implicitly, that it will do, then the pact is broken. Examples: a comedy that does not make us laugh, a ‘feature article’ that offers only surface level analysis, information advertised as a ‘revelation’ that tells us nothing new, etc.
The intentionality factor
A narrative, although formally perfect, may fail to win our complicity if the narrating agent does not engage on a personal level.
The sincerity factor
For further details on the narrative pact function:
Narrative pact function
Avenues for reflexions
and resources
Narrative pact function
Ask your questions,
have your say
