Casablanca, script by J.J. and P.G. Epstein, H. Koch, directed by M. Curtiz, 1942
What is not known about a character (retention/mystery) can lead the receiving agent to formulate hypothesis.
It would be tempting to think that Ilsa’s ‘betrayal’ in Paris is the primary event that gives rise to the plot narrated in Casablanca.
But the consequences of this event in Rick’s life could have been quite different.
After the disappointment that ends his relationship with Ilsa in Paris, Rick might have wanted to turn the page and decide to go underground somewhere in France to continue his fight against fascism, which he had already done in Spain and Ethiopia.
Instead, he runs away and we find him in Casablanca, morally broken, having disowned his past struggles and taking a cynical look at the despair around him. He befriends a corrupt policeman, becomes an accomplice in a black market racket and has one-night stands with vulnerable young women (including Yvonne, a true Ilsa lookalike). He drowns his spleen in bourbon and confesses his wanderings in Moroccan brothels to anyone who will listen.
In short, Rick has fallen very low.
Such an extreme reaction for a man of his age (is Bogart too old for the role of a young man of about 28?) can only be the result of a deeper cause which leads him to believe that his life is irretrievably over because a woman has rejected him, an irresistible force which maintains his victim status…
Questions are asked by the other characters about the American’s past, including why he can’t return to his homeland, but the real question is the essence of this protagonist, the mystery of this big-hearted adventurer’s fundamental suffering.
An event in Rick’s past must have produced the breeding ground for his emotional immaturity.
As with all these systemic causes, which are most often detectable after very long and thorough work on oneself (psychoanalysis, etc.), we will not be informed.
This mystery is only a “red herring” with no function for the plot, but which helps to make the character universal: aren’t we all tempted by despair at one time or another?

