Is there life beyond the narrative?
dpa picture alliance / Alamy Stock Photo
On a website dedicated to the narrative arts, it would be tempting to argue that the quality of a narrative work depends primarily on the merits of its narrative components and their composition. However, other ‘discourses’ also contribute, sometimes decisively, to its impact.
The aim of this website is to demonstrate that a successful narrative fulfils three basic narrative functions (narrative pact, cognition, emotions) by using narrative tools to “represent” a plot in which the protagonist(s) face plausible obstacles, leading to interesting, revealing and moving consequences.
What is the purpose
of
narratives?
The narrative discourse is just one component of literary, film, theater, visual, acoustic, plastic language
It should be noted that even in so-called classical narration, where all resources are used to “serve the story”, very few works are exclusively narrative.
More often than not, words, images and sounds do more than simply represent events. They also make it possible to see, read and hear other “content” that can serve the plot and contribute to its representation:
– A non-narrative descriptive discourse represents people, things and facts before or after they are involved in an event. The camera may linger on a landscape, an element of the setting or a character, even if they have no direct connection with the plot.
– An argumentative discourse is when a character, who may or may not be part of the plot, comments on the action, gives free rein to their ideas (“stream of consciousness”), analyses a situation, expresses their opinions and emotions.
– Informational discourse focuses on the workings of a thing or process without comment or judgement.
– An injunctive discourse demands or imposes an action, behaviour or opinion with authority and emphasis.
– A poetic-lyrical discourse appeals to our subjective sense of beauty.
The narrating agent can thus at any time become a non-narrating agent (descriptive, argumentative, etc.).
In artistic creativity, this versatility has the potential to be meaningful.
A narrative is more or less narrative in nature
The degree to which a medium tells a story is called “narrativity”.
High “narrativity” works represent many events, the input of the narrating agent is easily recognizable (e.g. the choice of obstacles), non-narrative discourses are scarce.
Low narrativity media leave a lot of space for non-narrative discourses, and the narrating agent’s contribution to the plot and its narration is less prominent.
The competences of a narrative work ensure its success
The vast majority of bestsellers and blockbusters belong to the “classical narration” type of storytelling. Their components and structure are precisely codified: a “relatable” plot and protagonists (whom we can like and empathize with), and numerous events told in a clear, direct, lively and transparent way (no Genette’s “metalpesis”…)
A competent narrative, i.e. one that manages to fulfil the three narrative functions, is one of the conditions required for a public and probably commercial success.
Storytelling has an almost supernatural power
Sometimes a narrative can make you forget about the lack of originality of the plot, its predictable ending and its irrelevance. The natural act of “telling a story” (humans have a narrative ‘organ’ that is unique among living things) has a hypnotic power, in that it can evoke powerful, archaic emotions in its audience. These effects are universally expected from stories.
In storytelling, the organ creates the function.
Incompetent storytelling can sometimes be no obstacle to a work’s conceptual and formal success
A “good story”, badly told, can still find an audience in spite of everything. A decent work can be the result of a banal plot told by an uninspired narrating agent. These books sell, they please the critics, these films win “best screenplay” awards.
This fact seems to confirm the hypothesis that a narrative is not a panacea, and that perhaps non-narrative elements sometimes manage to sublimate the narrative by compensating for its shortcomings? The debate is open.
A few examples of factors that can contribute to the success of an artistic work, beyond the narrative aspect:
• The appeal of novelty – Anything that is new, original, unusual (situation, ideas, images, style, point of view, atmosphere, etc.) produces a form of surprise which, although originally non-narrative, and even unrelated to the plot, or even devoid of any valuable meaning, opens the doors to an unknown world and therefore inevitably appeals to the natural curiosity and self-preservation instincts of human beings.
Neurologists believe that exposure to novelty stimulates brain functions. KNUTSON (Brian) COOPER (Jeffrey C.) The Lure of the Unknown [in] “Neuron, Vol. 51, issue 3, August 3, 2006
• The attraction of ritual – Beyond their role as narrating agents – who bring a personal point of view to their roles – performers are nonetheless human beings who engage in a fascinating, almost sacrificial ritual of transformation, embodiment, concrete identification (= “being in someone else’s shoes”). This whole process can in itself be a form of narrative that can compensate for a flawed plot or its incompetent telling.
The
sincerity factor
• The appeal of truth (and subsequently of fame) The identity and personality of the narrating agent can sometimes take precedence over the plot. Through their narrative choices, the receiving agent has access to their intimate inner worlds, conflicts and truths.
What does the narrating agent
want?
• The attraction of complexity. Sometimes a narrative encourages the receiving agent to concentrate on the pursuit of only one of the narrative functions, usually the cognitive function one. Empathy, sympathy and identification are irrelevant. The work is reduced to a cerebral exercise similar to completing a crossword puzzle, where the pleasure comes from the logical, reasoned placement of letters in boxes, to the detriment of the emotional connections generated by the arrangement of words in a sentence.
• The receiving agent’s familiarity with a particular narrative (especially its protagonists and their world) can create connections other than those created by the narrative itself (identification, empathy, etc.) The receiving agent may know more about fictional characters than real people close to them. Long-running TV series can create a sense of community and therefore play a social role.
CHALMERS (D.), O’DONNELL (H.) Going Native: Long-running Television Serials in the UK’, Series, [in:] “International Journal of TV Serial Narratives”, vol. 4, no. 1, 1, pp. 9-20. https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.2421-454X/8396
ESQUENAZI (Jean-Pierre) Télévision : la familiarité des publics avec leurs séries, Réseau Canopé « Idées économiques et sociales » 2009/1 N° 155, pages 26 à 31

