Select Page

“Extradiegetic” Point of View

A point of view is delineated by the answers to the following questions: who sees? Who hears? Who understands? Who interprets what is transmitted to us in writing, visually, through a sound medium or any material?

The “extradiegetic” narrating agent is not part of the plot, or their are but their speech is a non-narrative discourse.

The “implied author” may leave some doubts about the identity of who is narrating.

Examples of the use of the Extradiegetic Point of View to fulfil a specific narrative function* :

* This narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.

Extradiegetic Point of View

Narrative pact

Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.

»

Extradiegetic Point of View

Cognitive experience

Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.

»

Extradiegetic Point of View

Emotional experience

Probe and share all kind of emotions.

»

Key Points:

  • The “extradiegetic” narrative may be in the first, third or, more rarely, second person

It depends on whether or not the narrating agent wishes to associate their own world with that of the plot or with that of the receiving agent.

  •  “Extradiegetic” point of view : preliminary questions

1. What are the advantages (distanciation, etc.) of this type of narrating agent over the other ones?

2. Who is the “extradiegetic” narrating agent addressing?

An anonymous entity, a consumer of the narrative (readers, spectators, listeners) or a specific receiving agent?

3. What are the influences of this “narratee”?

4. Why is the narrating agent interested in the plot?

Is there a reason behind the desire to narrate this particular plot ?

  • A suspicious narrating agent

The credibility and motivations of the narrating agent who reports facts that they didn’t take part in, is subject to the scrutiny of the receiving agent (the contribution of factors such as competence, believability, retention is assessed and interpreted), their opinions, their style too.

This point of view is never totally neutral and reveals the narrative agent’s world that the receiving agent tries to identify by deduction, cross-checking, analyzing.

  • The “extradiegetic” narrating agent as an undercover character of the plot

The narrating agent is often implicitly/conventionally the “author” (writer, director, etc.) or a not specified entity, but it can also represent the stream of consciousness point of view of a character who belongs to the plot. Their identity can be revealed during the course of the narrative or left to the receiving agent’s interpretation (retention, mystery).

  • This point of view allows the receiving agent to explore the implications of the absence of concrete links between the world of a narrating agent and the world of the plot.

Nevertheless, these two worlds may compete, overlap, or complement each other in some way. The number and relevance of the narrative knots that the confrontation of these two worlds can generate is one of the criteria for choosing an “extradiegetic” narrating agent.

  • The “extradiegetic” narrating agent administers “non-textual narratives”, i.e. works that are presented to an audience (theater, animated images, visual arts)

In cinema, the term “ocularization” (F. Jost) is used to designate what is shown and what the characters see. 

This narrating agent can potentially see, hear, understand everything, and can choose not to show, hear or explain parts of the plot (retention). 

This narrating agent is restricted by visual technical constraints, unless they use artificial narrative devices such as oral comments (“voice-over”) or texts (subtitles, filmed intertitles, etc.)

  • The case of the “extradiegetic” narrating agents in non-textual narratives

In the past, scholars have contested that theatre, cinema and television were narrative, because they are mostly devoid of the oral discourse of a narrator, a necessary condition in their eyes. For various reasons, they did not consider the “implied author” to be a systematic ‘extradiegetic’ narrating agent of these acted narratives, nor, for that matter, the other “extradiegetic” narrating agents who were responsible for fundamental decisions related to the narrative (directors, actors, set designers, musicians, etc.)

A counterexample is improvisation theatre (“improv games”, etc.). These shows are only partially narrative due to the fact that they lack a narrative agent. The spectators arrive knowing that nobody on stage is aware of the plot. What they see are events happening in front of them, unnarrated, free of any point of view apart from their own.

  • A selective or non-selective point of view

It is possible that, although not belonging to the world of the plot, the narrating agent presents the events of the plot through the eyes, thoughts and sensibilities of only one of the protagonists (“polarized focalization”). This “extradiegetic” narrative agent often has the ability to read thoughts (“internal focalization”).

But the narrating agent may also not focus on a particular character (“zero focalization”) or focus on a group of characters (“selected focalization”).

  • Indirect speech in writing

In texts, the free or not “indirect speech” is, for an “extradiegetic” narrating agent, endowed with the means of the “internal focalization”, a way to transmit/hide behind the point of view of one of the protagonists of the plot.

Example: “He stopped at the side of the road and thought about the trials he had been through. Hadn’t his competitive spirit got the better of him?”

For Further Details on Extradiegetic Point of View:
Extradiegetic Point of View

Avenues for reflections and resources

»

Extradiegetic Point of View

Ask your questions,
have your say

»