Select Page

The Distanciation Factor

To distance oneself is to take a step back from something, in order to eventually try another approach.

In the narrative arts, this something is mainly the plot and its constituents, but also the narrative and its representation.

Examples of the use of the Distanciation to fulfil a specific narrative function* :

* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.

Distanciation

Narrative pact

Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.

»

Distanciation

Cognitive experience

Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.

»

Distanciation

Emotional experience

Probe and share all kind of emotions.

»

Key Points:

  • In use since time immemorial

In the traditional theatrical works of Asia (Iran, India, Thailand, China), distancing manifests itself mainly through ironic interpretation by the actors and the breaking down of the “fourth wall”.

Theorised by the Russian formalists at the beginning of the 20th century, this technique was systematised by Bertolt Brecht thirty years later in Germany.

His Verfremdungseffeckt (alienation effect), applied to social epic theatre, aims to prevent the audience from falling under the spell of the immersive device of the performance, to stop their emotional investment in the characters (empathy) and to invite them to engage their intellect to analyse the reality of the world and to define the means to change it.

Brechtian storytelling applies the distancing factor to narrative and dramaturgical tools in order to sublimate the cognitive experience of its audience.

  • Distanciation is often a means of resisting realism

But it can also be aimed at other notions such as the predictable, the unpredictable, expectations, conventions.

  • The distanciation felt by the receiving agent may not have been intended by the narrating agent

A “distancing” effect is one of the symptoms presented by a narrative that does not take into account the reality of the world it describes, a narrating agent who is blind to certain aspects of their story or who succumbs to the siren song of ease, hackneyed clichés and other mercantile indulgences (sentimentality, various manipulations, superficiality, style without substance, etc.)

  • The most popular type of distanciation: comedy

– The purpose of comedy is to provoke laughter.

– There are two categories of laughter: the first is a natural reflex which does not call upon any emotional or intellectual capacity, the second is associated with an implicit content which could not have been represented in a ‘serious’ mode (at least according to the opinion of the narrating agent).

– The first laughter, as a means of communication and social expression (the group laughs at the outlier and thus reaffirms its status), is strongly dependent on the specific values of the society from which it emanates. This explains, for example, why many comedy films that are huge commercial successes in their countries of production do not manage to generate the same enthusiasm in other countries).

– The second is produced by a comic distanciation at the level of the narrative, which releases what is not said and makes its expression ‘acceptable’. Distanciation takes us away from reality for a moment to allow us to grasp its most subterranean components (pious lies, taboos, ‘painful’ truths, repressed emotions, the ‘hanging man’s laugh’, etc.).

– Comic distanciation produces laughter that reveals meaning, whereas in social comedy laughter is a mere linguistic sign.

– Comic distanciation may occur occasionally in works belonging to non-comic genres (tragedy, psychological, sociological, romantic drama, etc.), comedic works (social comedy) or works combining the comic register with the non-comic register, such as ‘dramatic comedy’.

 

Drama Comedy
The plot consists of facts and events with potentially ‘serious’ consequences. The narrative ‘takes the plot seriously’. Most of its elements do not make the reader, viewer or listener laugh. The protagonists are multidimensional characters. The narrative is intended to make us laugh. The consequences of the facts and events in the plot are harmless (even if they’re potentially dangerous). The protagonists are two–dimensional characters.

The comic register covers a wide range of degrees of humour and tone: Fable, comedy of manners, vaudeville, Commedia dell Arte, farce, satire, pastiche, etc.

Dramatic comedy (comedy drama)

It is a work whose plot is “taken seriously” but whose singularity of the protagonist and/or other characters deviates from the accepted norms of social life, attracts our attention and amuses us. ‘Dramatic comedy’ is a genre that deals with the place of one or more individuals in the social group.

For Further Details on Distanciation:
Distanciation

Avenues for reflections and resources

»

Distanciation

Ask your questions,
have your say

»