Select Page

Argumentative Discourse

The primary purpose of an argumentative discourse is to convince its public of the accuracy, value, legitimacy, and relevance of a fact, an idea, an opinion, a thesis, or an emotion.

An argumentative discourse slows down the flow of the narrative.

On this site, the narrating agent becomes a argumentative agent when they produce an argumentation.

Examples of the use of the Argumentative Discourse to fulfil a specific narrative function* :

* This narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.

Argumentative Discourse

Narrative pact

Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.

»

Argumentative Discourse

Cognitive experience

Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.

»

Argumentative Discourse

Emotional experience

Probe and share all kind of emotions.

»

Key Points:

  • An argument is a finite set of argumentative elements.

It consists of a “conclusion” (opinion, concept, thesis, hypothesis) and one or more arguments that are supposed to prove the relevance of the “conclusion”. These arguments can take various forms: restatements, descriptions, illustrations, examples, counterexamples, comparisons with other theses, references to authoritative sources, rhetorical figures, etc.

An argument, made by the narrating agent interrupts the narrative thread of the actions and events. It contributes to the slowing down (or “expansion”, or “thickening”) of a narrative.

  • An argumentative element constitutes a partial, transitory or brief argument without giving the impression of suspending the narrative.

An argumentative element is not only expressed with words, words and images, but also in an indirect and/or implicit way. We can consider, for example, that all narration has an argumentative component (among other things, that of convincing us of its authenticity, of its realism), that a purely descriptive passage can have a persuasive function and that the expression of an opinion is one of the conditions of originality…

Two examples of argumentative elements :

After his embarrassment and his unreasoning joy he was consumed with wonder at her presence. He had been full of the idea so long, dreamed it right through to the end, waited with his teeth set, so to speak, at an inconceivable pitch of intensity. Now, in the reaction, he was running down like an over-wound clock.

The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1925

A minute later she asked me if I loved her. I told her it didn’t mean anything but that I didn’t think so. She looked sad.

The Stranger, Albert Camus, 1942, transl. by Matthew Ward

  • An argumentative tension point reveals the unusual, the unexpected, the unknown, the unpredictable

It provokes the incursion of surprise into the argumentative discourse, through its content and/or form.

Your friends need to be chaperoned, otherwise they’ll get away… Look at poor Yvan, whose chaotic behaviour used to delight us, we’ve allowed him to become timid… a stationer…

Art, Yasmina Reza, 2009

  • Argumentation and argumentative element: Preliminary questions.

1. Does the narrating agent have any convictions?

Note that doubt can be a form of belief (philosophy).
Intentionality can be an indicator of the presence of beliefs. Isn’t the very act of narrating itself the result of a conviction?

2. If the narrating agent has convictions, do they want to convince (reason) or persuade (emotions) a receiving agent of the accuracy and relevance of their ideas?

They may want to share their opinions without trying to support a thesis and influence someone: arguments without argumentation. We would then speak of “deliberation”, “refutation”, “exploration of a subject”, etc.

3. Through what channel does the narrating agent choose to convey their opinions and the arguments that are supposed to convince and persuade their audience?

– The argumentative discourse. A character expresses an opinion, supporting it with one or several arguments, in order to achieve one of the objectives of the plot.

Cavalier: A little glass for the marquis (To servant)
The Marquis: Not such a little glass either
[objective]. Burgundy isn’t a cordial [thesis]. To judge it one has to drink enough ot it. [argument]

The Mistress of the Inn, Carlo Goldoni,1752, transl. Merle Pierson

– The direct-explicit channel: The narrative thread is interrupted by an argument whose origin (the “implied author”) is not in doubt. Example: La Fontaine’s fables.

– The indirect-explicit channel: An argument or argumentative elements are given by a narrating agent. This choice (frequently employed in theater) can constitute a departure from the principle of cohesive characterization and raise the question of whether the characters are/should/can be the spokespersons of the “implied author”. Example: Candide at the end of Voltaire’s Candide?

– The implicit channel. There is no concrete argumentative element, but the narrative is a form of reasoning (e.g. argumentative demonstration) intended to prove or disprove a given proposition in support of a thesis. Example: Groundhog Day, film written by Danny Rubin and Harold Ramis, 1993. The Plague, Albert Camus, 1942, a philosophical novel about totalitarianism.

The title of a work can take on an implicit argumentative value. For example: A Doll’s House (Et Dukkehjem), Henrik Ibsen, 1879. A play about the fate of a woman husband or wife dominated by paternalistic men.

  • Arguments and argumentative elements generate meaning whose ultimate purpose may be to:

– Pursue an explicit objective, defined as a result of the final plot event, or an implicit objective (story).

– Convince us of the reality or plausibility of the world(s) in the narrative (narrative pact).

– Convince us of the skill of the narrating agent (narrative pact),

– Connect us to the mode of reasoning of the narrating agent (cognitive experience)

– Forge our emotional convictions (emotional experience)

– Satisfy our desire for knowledge (cognitive experience).

  • A comparison (cohesion factor) is argumentative when it involves irony, mockery or value judgment (cognitive function).

Example: “In this case, the president is behaving like a carpet merchant”

  • An argument can be structured by the application of the  factors cohesion and speed.

In narrative works, the arguments are most often inscribed in the timeline of the narrative. Example:

[…] that the purpose of life was not the maintenance of well-being, but some intensification and refining of consciousness, some enlargement of knowledge. Which was, the Controller reflected, quite possibly true. But not, in the present circumstance, admissible. He picked up his pen again, and under the words “Not to be published” drew a second line, thicker and blacker than the first; then sighed, “What fun it would be,” he thought, “if one didn’t have to think about happiness!

Brave New World, Aldous Huxley, 1932

For Further Details on Argumentative Discourse:
Argumentative Discourse

Avenues for reflections and resources

»

Argumentative Discourse

Ask your questions,
have your say

»