The Stakes-Risks Factor
The stakes and risks factor is applied to a narrative tool when the concrete consequences of a decision or action are brought to the attention of the protagonist and/or the receiving agent.
* A narrative tool (let’s compare it to a hammer) used under certain conditions, or factor (precision and force for the hammer), allows certain practical results to be obtained (to knock in a nail in order to hang a picture). But this result is usually in the service of a more meaningful purpose (to decorate, to seduce an audience, to display beliefs, etc.) that we call on this site: narrative function.
Narrative pact
Project ourselves into imaginary or real world possibilities.
»
Cognitive experience
Improve our understanding of the world in which we live and of ourselves.
»
Emotional experience
Probe and share all kind of emotions.
»
Key Points:
-
A “survival” factor (physical and psychological)
Characters in narrative works never attain the complexity of real people.
The strongest tensions come from the stakes and risks related to survival, security, freedom, identity. For example: In William Styron’s Sophie’s Choice (1979), a mother has to choose which of her children will survive. Or in Star Wars, when Luke discovers that the worst enemy he is fighting, Darth Vader, is his father.
Moral dilemmas (Cornelian choices), with no potential impact on events, are intrapersonal obstacles.
• This factor can be found in the three levels of the narrative ecosystem:
- “Diegetic” level:
– Choices made by the protagonists (the objectives and strategies to achieve them), especially the protagonist of the plot who should be the one who has the most to risk and for whom the consequences of events have the most impact.
- Narrating agent’s level:
– Choice of narrative tools (creation of the narrative, artistic choices).
– Decision to produce a narrative (the personal cost of telling a story. The consequences of the narrative on the receiving agent).
- Receiving agent level:
– to consume a certain narrative can be, in some parts of the world and at certain times, a dangerous activity. Knowledge always has a risk dimension.
-
This factor goes hand in hand with the event or narrative knots
– Stake(s) : The expected and foreseeable outcome of the protagonist’s action (reaching or not reaching their objective).
– Risk(s): The possible adverse, unpredictable, or unknown consequences of the protagonist’s action to achieve their objective.
• There are unknown (and therefore unpredictable and normally… unforeseen) stakes and risks
They can lead to unexpected obstacles or outcomes (certain contingent events, a “deus ex-machina”).
The receiving agent may discover, at the same time as the protagonist, an unforeseen or unpredictable risk when an action has not produced the expected result (event or narrative knot), but our experience is more intense if we are made aware of this risk before the protagonist makes a decision (subtext, suspense, “dramatic irony”).
• Stakes are always uncertain
While risks are more or less ‘probable’ (cognitive experience), stakes are subject to uncertainty, the unpredictability of which feeds our emotional experience (e.g. suspense).
• A particular risk: obtaining the result we hoped for… but which does not fulfil the role we had assigned to it
This is a form of error pertaining to the function of the objective, revealing the internal conflicts of the protagonist. “Be careful what you wish for, it could happen…”.
• A criterion for choosing the protagonist
Sometimes the character chosen to be the protagonist of the plot is not the most suitable. The stakes and risks associated with that person are not sufficiently meaningful.
Avenues for reflections and resources
»
Ask your questions,
have your say
»
