You have
an obstacle
Now you’re looking for
an action
Key points to consider and examples
• On the condition that the protagonist enjoys all their mental faculties, a protagonist chooses (consciously or not) an action according to an objective.
A donkey dies (obstacle) in spite of the care (actions) given to it by its owner (logical objective).
• But not always, and you will have to use your imagination and hope to generate the surprise effect that will provide revelation and meaning.
The donkey is starving (obstacle) because his owner had stopped feeding him (action) in order to save money (objective)… The protagonist is stingy, naive, or stupid.
• The choice of action can/should reveal the personality of the protagonist, their state of mind, their capacities (characterization). As such it can generate a surprise.
In Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina, at the Bobristhchiff ball, Anna does not want to dance (objective). She refuses the offer of the elegant George Korsunsky (action), but when Wronsky arrives (obstacle) she changes her mind (new action and new objective: to get away from Wronsky by dancing with Korsunsky).
Key questions
⇒ What was the protagonist doing/what were they trying to do when they were confronted with this specific obstacle?
⇒ Is there a cause-and-effect relationship between the obstacle and the action?
⇒ What action can both surprise us and convince us of its plausibility and inevitability?
Explore all the possible pairs (obstacle + action)…
My protagonist, faces [this obstacle], while doing [that]
-
Without censoring yourself…
-
Without being afraid of making a mistake or writing something stupid…
-
Without hesitating to explore the wackiest combinations…
-
Without deciding on any combination for the moment…
When you feel you have explored as many obstacle + action pairs as possible, you can move on to a situation:
Continue here
»
Here are some suggestions for boosting your creativity:
• Leave your fear of failure or error or ridicule behind.
• Human beings are unable to imagine anything that does not belong to their universe. The creative function is a transformation.
• Novelty and insight arise from new arrangements, not from new information.
• Beware of automatic thinking patterns generated by consensus. Be resistant! (1) Define what is expected, explore its opposite.
• Be playful! Try different juxtapositions that are purely random and experimental (play with what you have and give luck a chance).
• Knowing too much can be detrimental to the development of new ideas. Do something new with what you have.
• The data accumulation phase (the one you are in now) can easily give a false sense of security, at the risk of creating linear thinking…
• We are ALL resistant to change and afraid of the unexpected… yet we are unable to live without them.
• Simplify by reducing information to its essence.
• Dissect! Break it down!
• “We build too many walls, not enough bridges” (Isaac Newton).
• Pay attention to the details, even the most insignificant ones, and test all kinds of associations between them.
• Make a list of ideas and combine incompatible ones.
• Leave the frontal approach and explore the side roads.
• Test other points of view than your protagonist’s, even if they don’t belong in the situation.
• Go through the incubation phase before making any decisions. Do something else for a few minutes/hours/days/years… The material needs to brew. Originality is a distillate.
• Give your unconscious mind a chance to forge new alliances / considerations / recombinations..
• Your goal: Poincaré’s dazzling enlightenment (2). Most striking at first is this appearance of sudden illumination, a manifest sign of long, unconscious prior work…
• The human capacity for invention has long intrigued scientists. This interest has generated numerous theories and methods (3). More recently, neuroscience claims, with varying degrees of accuracy, to be able to map the neural pathways of the imagination. Developments in Artificial Intelligence are rushing to extract/mimic/model the computational intelligence of our future creative partners, the robots (4)…
1 The Einstellung effect, also known as problem solving set, is a mental posture consisting in prioritizing, for a given problem, a less efficient solution, but one that is well mastered/known even if more efficient, simple or appropriate solutions exist (Wikipedia)
2 One day, while walking on the cliff, the idea came to me, always with the same characteristics of brevity, suddenness and immediate certainty…“
Poincaré H., “L’invention mathématique,” Bulletin de l’Institut général psychologique, 8th year, No. 3, May-June 1908, reproduced in Hadamard J., Essais sur la psychologie de l’invention dans le domaine mathématique, Paris, Éditions Jacques Gabay, 2011, p. 141.
3 The ASIT creativity method. Brainstorming by Alex Osborn. Creative Problem Solving by Alex Osborn and Sid Parnes. The Design Sprint by Jake Knape. Lateral thinking and hats by Edward de Bono. The challenge-storming by Jean-Louis Swiners and Jean-Michel Briet. The Phoenix Game by Vincent Cespedes. Synectics by William Gordon. Creative intelligence. Abraham Moles’ discovery matrices. Business wargames. TRIZ by Genrich Altshuller. Bissociation by Arthur Koestler. Mind Mapping by Tony Buzan. Guy Aznar’s detour techniques. The C-K theory by Armand Hatchuel and Benoît Weil, etc.
4 Anna Abraham, The Neuroscience of Creativity (Cambridge Fundamentals of Neuroscience in Psychology. December 6, 2018). The first textbook on the neuroscience of creativity. A pointed example: Antonio Lieto, Gian Luca Pozzato. Applying a Description Logic of Typicality as a Generative Tool for Concept Combination in Computational Creativity. Universita degli Studi di Torino, August 2019. “In this work we exploit a nonmonotonic Description Logic of typicality as a tool for the generation and the exploration of novel creative concepts.”
