Select Page

The content on this page undergoes regular updates and additions.

Surprise: Avenues of reflection and resources

• Surprise is a reaction provoked by the revelation of a new reality

In a narrative work, it is the main effect of an event, a narrative knot, or a narrative tension point.

It encompasses the spectacular, the unusual, the magical, the fantastic, the bizarre, the mysterious, everything that excites the attention of a character and/or the receiving agent.

• It is a key component in a narrative work as an open door to a world we do not yet know, the ultimate purpose of art

The surprise is a symptom of a form of error (which can also be called ignorance, naivety, lack of curiosity, prejudice, etc.) It prompts us (the character and/or the receiving agent) to reflect on what we have missed in this world that has caught us unaware, what this hiatus can reveal to us about the world and ourselves (“insight”).

• Surprise can vary from a slight astonishment to dismay, or even vasovagal syncope, which may obstruct other kind of response 

Its intensity can vary according to three main variants:

– Its frequency. Too much surprise causes fatigue, boredom, a form of desensitization (indifference). Montesquieu said that the fundamental need of the soul is to feel and not to feel too much; this is remedied by varying its modifications.

– Its quality. Surprise summons consciousness (see Paul Valéry). Surprise for the sake of surprise, or surprise that is too quickly transformed into admiration or simple contemplation, does not allow one to “see better” or “see differently” reality.

– Its function (aesthetic of alterity). Confronting a protagonist with ALL possible obstacles, in order to multiply the experience of surprise, can kill meaning through lack of choice (cultivating surprise for surprise’s sake).

To find a very large number of different feelings which concur to shake it [the soul] and to compose a pleasure for it.

MONTESQUIEU

Essay on taste 1757

• Surprise and descriptive / argumentative / poetic-lyrical discourses, the descriptive / argumentative tension point

A description or an argumentation can surprise the receiving agent for reasons that are personal and subjective to them (simple astonishment? cultural specificity?)

A description or a poetic-lyrical discourse can provoke a predictable aesthetic surprise thanks to an unforeseen, unpredictable, or singular element, without inducing a change in the state or direction of the plot as in an event. We will say that this description contains a descriptive tension point.

Example: The locomotive’s whistle sent out a plaintive, mournful cry; never had the horror of the storm seemed so beautiful to Anna. (Anna Karenina loc 2338) The description of the locomotive’s departure into the storm is “tensed” by the oxymoron horror/beauty.

The surprise factor may lie in the originality, elegance of logic or outrageousness of an argument.

• Narrative tension

This is a generic term for the emotional effects and acquisition of new knowledge created by the transition from the known, the expected and the predictable to the unknown, the unexpected and the unpredictable (surprise).

The known, the expected and the predictable surprise no-one. They reassure us and mark the way along the path to our destiny. They nourish the intuitive and are the breeding ground for heuristic judgements. But very quickly they become monotonous and boring, and then a paradoxical and surprising syndrome arises: the event generating self-sabotage.

The unknown surprises us in proportion to our capacity for curiosity and wonder. This capacity is very high in young children and diminishes over the years, except in those who have retained a part of the child they once were. Human beings are naturally motivated to solve mysteries (a survival instinct).

The unexpected surprises us before possibly making us angry. It induces a certain degree of guilt for having been caught in the act of carelessness, of lack of anticipation.  The unexpected brings us back to our limits, to our mistakes.

The unpredictable briefly surprises us, before quickly sending us into the throes of a feeling of powerlessness. It’s an open door to a world where none of our references work anymore?

Narrative tension is generated not only by the events of the plot but also by the narrative, i.e. the choices made by the narrating agent in terms of the representation/description of non-verbal actions, landscapes, settings, situations, thoughts, atmosphere, etc.), the comments, opinions, digressions, the verbal actions represented or reported (dialogue), and the narrating agent’s management of the disclosure of information. In this case it is the consumer of the narrative work who finds themselves in the situation of a protagonist whose achievement of the objective (understanding the message) is thwarted by the narrating agent’s biases, such as retention, fragmentation, non-linearity, misinformation (“unreliable narrator”), change of focus, and so on.

There are two types of narrative tension: that which results from an event whose consequences are such that they induce a change of objective and strategy on the part of the protagonist (= the character who has made the choice of objective and strategy), or a change in the direction of the plot, or even of the narrative. We’ll call this type of event a narrative knot.

When the unknown, the unforeseen or the unpredictable produce a surprise effect with no consequences for the plot (facts, events, direct discourse) or the other elements of the narrative (descriptions, arguments/injunctions, indirect discourse, poetic discourse), then this is a point of narrative tension.

• Other propositions:

– The astonishment aroused by reality would be the triggering feeling of a “philosophical attitude”, especially according to Socrates, who uses the word θαυμάζειν (thaumazein, which also means wonder) to designate this emotion.

– I never liked being surprised. When something happens to me, I prefer to be present. Albert Camus, L’Etranger, 1942. According to the argument of Camus’ narrator, presence is preferable to absence. Is art perhaps teaching us to be present ?

– About a painting by Raphael: The surprise is not represented, it is created by the insidious capture of our gaze: the surprised subject is not in the work, they are facing it, the surprise settles in progressively, by the deepening of our gaze. The surprise is mediocre at first, but progresses through our very attention, leading us from astonishment to admiration, which is a pleasant surprise.  (Dictionary of Arts and Emotions, Armand Colin, p 429)

– In George Orwell’s “1984”, the surprise is that one can no longer be surprised. The party controls the unexpected and the unknown.

– The quality of surprise gives an event its value. A surprise is fertile when the error it reveals is universal, relevant, meaningful, contentious, etc. A surprise without error concerns a mere impulsive reaction, pure instinct or arousal (e.g. voyeurism).

– A fanatic forbids themselves and others to be surprised. It is pointless to encourage a “fan” to analyze their favourite subject.

Death is a surprise that the inconceivable makes to the conceivable.

VALERY (Paul)

 It is surprise, astonishment that forces us to evolve.

 

MORIN (Edgard)