Select Page

The content on this page undergoes regular updates and additions.

The retention factor: Avenues of reflections and resources

• Retention challenges our (vital? Illusory? Limiting?) desire for coherence, order, normality and control of our destiny. Being confronted with the unknown and/or the secret triggers destabilising archaic anxieties in us.

• The autocratic power of the narrating agent vs. the dependent position of the receiving agent.

• When does an omission become a lie?

• A variant of retention: “paralipsis”. This is pretending not to mean what is nevertheless being said very clearly and sometimes forcefully (I will not speak of…).

• An example of the application of the retention factor to “characterization”: What would a character never say to family members, friends, colleagues, etc.? 

• In the case of a lack of information about a particular world (voluntary or involuntary retention), a simple action can communicate knowledge about this world. 

• The narrating agent may deliberately choose not to explain/justify the untimely appearance of fantastic, supernatural, unreal elements in a realistic narrative (e.g. ‘magical realism’).

• Human beings have a natural propensity not to trust appearances, to always explore non-literal space with suspicion. Is it the function of the arts to train us in this vital reflex for the survival of the species?

• Not representing certain facts (retention) can be used to make another fact unique and exceptional (lying by omission).

There is the visible and the invisible. If you only film the visible, you’re making a TV movie not cinema

GODARD (Jean-Luc)

• A silence that speaks volumes.

•  The “iceberg technique”: the narrating agent places as much information as possible outside the range of the receiving agent’s sight and hearing. The point of view is that of “external focalisation”, which stimulates the “narratee’s” curiosity and arouses their skills of deduction and interpretation. Its possible raison d’être:

          – To unconsciously present a deceptive appearance (front effect)

          – To consciously manipulate the receiving agent (including to deceive them)

          – To deceive oneself. 

• The audiovisual narrative may attempt to escape from its multi-informational nature (one image ‘says’ many things at once) by removing certain elements from the space represented, for example by limiting the light, the camera’s point of view, by making the setting abstract, etc. 

• “Cliffhanger”. The narrative ends before revealing all the components of a plot event : an action without its result, an obstacle without the reaction, a surprise without the obstacle that created it.

• “Red herring”. The narrating agent chooses to disclose information without telling the receiving agent that the information is not relevant.

• There is no real mystery in a narrative, only a withholding of information on the part of the narrating agent (they know).

• “Foreshadowing“ is a way of capturing the receiving agent’s attention. What’s the cost of captivity?

• Suspense can sometimes be applied to purely aesthetic objects: music, noise, ‘special’ effects. In cinema, certain camera angles can induce suspense without the stakes and risks of the situation necessarily being known to the receiving agent.

• The autocratic power of the narrating agent and the dependent position of the receiving agent (Hitchcockian “sadism”). 

• Theorists have not been able to agree on the causes of the persistence of suspense, i.e. when the receiving agent knows already the plot (e.g. after having read the same book several times) and the same emotions are triggered. Perhaps they should consider that this factor is not only applicable to the events of the plot, but also to the narrative tension points? The narrative itself can provoke the same affects as the factual uncertainties of the plot. 

• There is an existential dimension created by the ‘blindfolded’ journey of a character or characters towards an inevitable fate. Sometimes this fate is known even before the narrative begins and its presence in the work satisfies the audience’s expectations and support (Sophocles’ Oedipus King is based on a myth that was known to all. In Titanic, the eponymous ship sinks as planned…)