The Sopranos (1999-2007) TV Series created by David Chase, 86 episodes, HBO
The pursuit of a specific value can provide an implicit objective for a two-dimensional character, defined by a single, concrete, generic objective (e.g. survival) and by the strategy employed (e.g. violence).
Portrait of a Two-dimensional Character
In this flagship series of the early 21st century, the protagonist, Tony Soprano, an Italian-American gangster from New Jersey, suffers from recurring anxiety attacks (intrapersonal event) that threaten to tarnish his reputation as a tough guy (stakes & Risks factor, explicit objective: to survive and to thrive in the gangster world). He secretly consults a psychotherapist (strategy/action).
At the beginning of the series, the plot revolves around two pivotal events (plot knots): the illness and death of the clan leader Jackie Aprile, whom Tony eventually replaces, and the latter’s panic attacks.
The six seasons of the series explore the world of the New Jersey Mafia (Tony Soprano’s rise to the top and his career as “boss”), Tony’s personal world (his family, his mistresses, his hobbies, etc.) and his mental space (his anxiety attacks, his childhood memories, his nightmares, etc.).
These plots are not connected to a story (initial story event) that could have generated them. At no point in the series (and even “beyond” in the prequel film about Tony’s youth: The Many Saints of Newark, 2021) are we told or shown:
► the event that compelled Tony to join the mafia, despite being initially disgusted by his father’s criminal activities (in a “flashback” we even see him vomiting after having witnessed violence instigated by his father)
► the event that triggered his panic attacks (several assumptions are made, none of them conclusive). These attacks are somewhat forgotten for long stretches of the series, and the psychotherapy sessions become mere opportunities for Tony to confide in a “neutral” witness.
► The moments (events) when the non-criminal people around Tony (his wife, his children, his therapist, etc.), become aware of his belonging in a group of murderous criminals, and then decide to accept this state of affairs, not to run away from it, not to confront him with these acts and their consequences for the victims.
Tony is thus a two-dimensional character.
The protagonist, a stereotypical Italian American mafioso, pursues explicit objectives related to his professional activities and his family role without us really knowing what drives him or motivates him on an existential level (social revenge? Desire to fill a gap? To hide a complex? To reach an ideal? To repair a mistake of the past? Etc.)
Tony does not seem to have an implicit objective, a goal that a character is most often unable to describe, but that we (receiving agents) can identify.
The Risks of a Long Narrative
When the only criterion for choosing the obstacles encountered by a two-dimensional protagonist is operational logic, then the narrative is at risk of not rising above the level of a mere illustrative chronicle devoid of any meaningful input from the narrating agent.
This is far from being the case in this series.
An Inbuilt Quality
The reason is that the plot does not find its cohesion in its relation to a story, but in a key value, so important, vital even for the protagonist (since his childhood Tony has conformed to this value), that its preservation constitutes the equivalent of an implicit objective.
This value is loyalty, without which the world of organized crime implodes through clan wars and other bloody settlements of accounts.
Loyalty has been a core value of Tony’s identity (cohesion factor/conformism) since his early childhood, when his father used him (a form of betrayal) to conceal his criminal and extramarital activities.
Employed throughout the series to the test of the circumstances of the New Jersey gangsters’ lives and those of their families, this value offers the narrating agent the opportunity to expound their own views on the matter, including the role of loyalty as a substitute for fidelity, which is seen as vain and unattainable.
A Criterion for Selecting Obstacles
By selecting the obstacles that provide the most significant antagonisms to the value of “loyalty”, the narrative is not simply an account of plausible events but becomes a reasoned argument in support of a singular and personal point of view.
By way of illustration, here is a non-exhaustive list of areas explored throughout the series from the perspective of the role played by the value of “loyalty/trustworthiness”:
- The mafia system sanctifies the value of loyalty by way of “blood ceremonies”. In this environment, the slightest hint of betrayal leads to certain death.
- When Jackie Aprile dies, Tony installs his uncle Corrado as head of the family while pulling the strings behind his back (loyalty/trust).
- Tony’s own mother betrays him by plotting his assassination. Tony can’t blame her (loyalty to “the mama”).
- Junior, Tony’s uncle, almost kills him by shooting him, but the disease (Alzheimer’s) complicates the judgement (true betrayal or simple “infidelity” of reason?)
- His protégé, and potential successor, “nephew” Christopher Moltisanti, an impulsive young man frustrated by his boss’s lack of recognition, hijacks the contents of trucks under the Sopranos’ protection. His act is considered a simple infidelity, as Christopher remains loyal by paying his share to his boss.
- The therapy sessions lead Tony’s associates to question the loyalty of their boss: is he not passing sensitive information to his therapist that endangers the organization?
- The importance of Italian American culture, the memory of immigrant ancestors and the family that stayed in Italy throughout the series. The descendants of Italian emigrants remain loyal to their country of origin.
- Tony is loyal to his wife, but unable to be faithful to her.
- The “loyalty” of the children to their parents’ expectations/projections /fantasies/wishes (this is the mainspring of all situations in Tony’s family home).
- Is homosexuality (of one of the family capos) a breach of loyalty or just an infidelity to traditional macho values (Tony does not share his men’s strong opinion on this).

