You came up with many possible events and now you need to choose the ones that will constitute the plot.
• If you have already experienced Poincaré’s “dazzling illumination” and you are intuitively and irrefutably convinced of the excellence of each of the events, go directly to the next step:
Continue here
»
• If you don’t know if an event is suitable or not…
• If you can’t select the events you need for the plot…
• If you can’t decide what version of an event to choose…
I suggest three criteria to help you decide:
Criterion #1: Credibility.
Does the protagonist have the consciousness/capacities/motivations to desire what they desires?
Is what they are undertaking compatible with their personality, physical, mental, moral abilities, etc.?
Criterion #2: The potential insight (the values at stake, the meaning).
What does the protagonist’s choice of objective reveal (about themselves, about their world, about our world)?
What does their choice of action reveal?
What does their surprise when faced with the unknown, the unexpected or the unpredictable tell us?
Criterion #3: The potential for reaction or outcome.
Does your event make us want to find out what happens next?
Does your event satisfy us as the ultimate denouement of the plot?
Applying the criteria to our “donkey” example
The owner of a donkey is very stingy. In order to avoid spending money, he wants to teach his donkey not to eat anymore. He stops feeding it. The donkey dies of hunger. His owner is surprised.
Credibility:
The protagonist’s obstacle and action seem to be in line with his greed.
Revealing potential:
The protagonist’s surprise confirms our doubts about the flaw of the character. We are not surprised. The unexpected outcome for the protagonist was, for us, predictable.
Does this mean that this event is not interesting?
To judge this, we must consider a third criterion, which derives from the very nature of an event, namely that it calls for a reaction and/or an outcome.
Potential for reaction:
The event we are examining creates an expectation (macro suspense) about the protagonist’s reaction (i.e. the next action).
The owner of the donkey chooses to say something as the action to achieve his new objective.
He says:
It’s too bad, he had started to learn…¹
His new objective is to justify his actions and deny the stupidity of his previous objective (= teaching the donkey to stop eating by stopping feeding him).
The protagonist’s reaction this time produces OUR surprise (“How can one be so dumb and blind?!”) AS WELL AS a revelation on two levels: a confirmation of the flaw in this individual’s character, but more importantly the realization that sometimes the solution to a problem can be worse than the problem itself…
Value is created…
¹ From Philogelos (Ancient Greek: Φιλόγελως, “Love of Laughter”), also titled or subtitled The Jests of Hierocles and Philagrius, is the oldest existing collection of jokes, written between the 3rd and 4th centuries.
You have selected one or more events based on these criteria.
If your work is a still image, you can find more commented examples here:
Still Images
»
Otherwise you can go to the next step:
Continue here
»
More about events ↓
More about events
• Not every event in a plot is spectacularly revealing. Reaching too often for dazzling insight runs the risk of didactic heaviness, or of exhausting our capacity to be surprised. It is all a question of balance. Ony the “implied author” can decide this.
• Insight is not just a dazzling discovery/revelation and instantaneous wonder (admiration + surprise), it also makes us learn something about ourselves. We cannot predict what will surprise us. We know only that we have committed some kind of error of judgment. The suspense that is created comes from the uncertain consequences of the revelation of our limitations (knowledge can be dangerous).
• Great art regenerates our perception of reality. It enriches it. (Gabriel Orozco)
