Select Page

The content on this page undergoes regular updates and additions.

The plausibility factor: Avenues for reflections and resources

  • For Aristotle (Poetics) the emotional effects of tragedy depend, among other things, on facts that “occur against our expectation, while flowing from each other, for they will then have the character of the marvellous more than if they were due to chance and fortune.”

The true may sometimes not be plausible

BOILEAU

Ars poetica, Canto III, 1674

• Plausibility can be a means of concealing the truth and gaining acceptance for specious ideas (this is often the case with conspiracy theories). 

• While implausibility may be real in the real world (including, but not limited to, coincidences), implausibility in fiction is always unreal and tests the credulity of the receiving agent. 

• A narrative may seem implausible because its narrating agent, intentionally or not, does not tell us the truth about the events of the plot. 

• Illogical behaviour can be plausible in reality as well as in fiction.

• Convincing people that real facts, past or present, are plausible is sometimes a major goal of the narrating agent of a non-fictional story. 

• The simple narration of a plot helps to make it plausible by “normalizing” its

• A narrative is an instrument of power. 

• Plausibility can be a barrier to accessing new knowledge and experience.

The world of the novel is only a rectification of the world we live in, in pursuance of man’s deepest wishes. For the world is undoubtedly the same one we know. The suffering, the illusion, the love are the same. The heroes speak our language, have our weaknesses and our strength. Their universe is neither more beautiful nor more enlightening than ours. But they, at least, pursue their destinies to the bitter end

CAMUS (Albert)

The Rebel, 1951, translated by Anthor Bower

A chimera is a being composed of incompatible parts, having for example the head of a lion, the body of a woman and the tail of a dragon. Of course, not all impossibilities are synonymous, but it is possible to represent them distinctly from each other. The proposition ‘the chimera is a chimera’ is true, and yet chimeras are impossible objects. For, on the other hand, the complex concept is composed of possible parts. One cannot think of an impossible object in itself, there is no impossible object, there are only possible objects that have impossible relations. It is also false to say: “I imagine a chimera”, because the chimera being impossible, I cannot imagine it. So there is room for a universe without truth value and yet about which we can say true things.

ASHWORTH (E.J.)

"Chimeras and Imaginary Objects: A Study in the post-medieval Theory of Signification". Studies in Post-medieval Semantics, London, 1985, pp. 57-79,. Reported by Olivier Boulnois "La création, l'art et l'original" in "Communication", 1997, no. 64, pp. 55-76